What happened to all the bass?

After a stop-start summer I was really looking forward to a lengthy spell of good bass fishing through the autumn and into winter. Well, basically it just didn’t happen. I managed quite a few trips right up until the end of the year, in between the storms, but the fish were hard to find – in fact the last bass I caught was on December 2nd.

So what happened to all the bass? You don’t have to look far to see what is the most likely cause. The amount of illegal netting for bass going on down here in Cornwall (which will have implications for stocks in other areas too) has been exposed by Save Our Sea Bass. Commercial overfishing has had an impact on stocks, and therefore on anglers’ catches, over the years; this may well have reached a tipping point in Cornwall, given what I, and other local anglers, have seen in 2020.

Diary review

This is where reality sets in – where we separate fact from impression! Going through my 2020 diary, I see that 62% of my 128 trips were blanks, and I managed just 118 bass from the remainder. The best of these was a modest 61cm, accompanied by just a handful of fish in the mid-late 50’s. It didn’t help that I lost the best fish of the year, a real bruiser which took a peeler crab, at my feet in October! August was my best month, accounting for 34 fish, including most of the ‘larger’ fish. Perhaps the only highpoint of the year was improving my estuary fishing.

It felt like 2020 had been the worst year I could recall, but when I went back to my 2019 diary, I was surprised by what I found. For a similar number of trips (110), I’d had a similar percentage of blanks (65%), but had actually caught fewer fish (87). Why then did it feel like 2020 had been such a poor year?

My collection of fishing diaries. Records stop us seeing the past through rose-tinted glasses.

The increased number of fish caught in 2020 (even this was modest) was consistent with slightly more trips than in 2019, but there was a big difference in the number of ‘quality’ fish caught. Whereas I only managed one fish over 60cm in 2020, in 2019  I caught 11, including 2 at 71cm (excluding my Guernsey fishing).

Some of this may have been down to a reluctance to fish further afield at times due to Covid, and a fair amount of experimenting with estuary marks, but these results are nonetheless pretty concerning.

Getting bigger

Going by the number of 60cm+ fish that  were around in 2019, I was expecting to see decent numbers of 65+cm fish last year, the fish having put on an extra year’s growth. I was also hoping there might be a realistic chance of a double, given that the 70cm fish which seemed to be cropping up regularly in catch reports later in the year would have grown to mid 70’s+

But Simon Toms, Cornish Federation of Sea Anglers fish recorder, notes that only 7 bass over 7lb were recorded from the shore, with the biggest just over 8lb. This despite a lot of anglers fishing for bass in good conditions (before the weather deteriorated in the autumn), who also noted the lack of larger bass. On the bright side, Simon notes that there were good numbers of 3 and 4lbers around.

Natural causes

It’s important to take a balanced view in these situations, and consider what else might be contributing to the picture. Are natural causes also playing a part?

The hoped-for boost in catches from migrating fish in late Oct, and again in mid Dec, didn’t materialise. There were reports of large shoals of bass further east in early December, and commercials seemed to be getting lots of bass in nets in Cornwall around this time, but this didn’t translate into improved catches for anglers. These bass were often stuffed with pilchards.

Bass will follow pilchards, and if you can intercept these baitfish, you could have a bass bonanza. Mostly though, the pilchards and the bass will be out of the shore angler’s reach, except perhaps when there’s a good onshore blow to push the pilchards in. Even boat anglers will struggle, trying to compete with all that natural bait, and with bass completely full, and not able to feed again until they have digested their last meal.

Pilchards (Sardina pilchardus), caught inshore during autumn 2020. Are the shoals off Cornwall increasing each year?
Photo: Stuart Martinez
A portly 55cm late November bass. This one looked like it had been pigging out on pilchards.

Simon Toms comments on a serious lack of mackerel close inshore from July to November last year, and thinks there is a link between this and the fewer big bass we saw. The regular occurrence of tuna close inshore may have had a bearing on both the presence of mackerel, and of  bass – either indirectly, by pushing their food source further out, or directly by the need to avoid these large predators.

A measure of success

With my diary review in mind, it’s interesting to think about what constitutes successful bass fishing to each of us. I don’t get too hung up on numbers of fish (unless of course we’re talking big ones!), but rather I think in terms of the number of successful sessions I’ve had in any given season. These might include sessions where I’ve caught half a dozen 2-3lbers, or at least one fish over 4lb. Some will think this is a pretty meagre measure of success, and my sights have lowered over the years as the quality of bass fishing has declined. Even by this yardstick my bass fishing in 2020 was poor, with only 9 successful trips. Red-letter days, with the landing of an 8lb+ fish, are becoming as rare as rocking horse poo!

But success isn’t just about results. If I happen to hit the mother lode, catching numbers of fish, in quick succession, rather than cash in, I use the opportunity to prove a new lure or bait. This usually results in fewer fish caught than if I had stuck with whatever I was using. But it can also lead to gaining confidence (or not) in new things, thereby potentially enhancing your overall fishing success and pleasure, and avoiding wasted time on things that don’t work for you.

Other measures of success include discovering new marks and new methods, or just simply enjoying time spent fishing in beautiful places and inspiring conditions, time which burns itself into your memory. Trying new marks can also result in fruitless sessions and lower catch figures, but this is a price I’m prepared to pay – up to a point.

Talking of measures of success, why not pick up one of the new BASS competition tapes?

Another year, another lure

I don’t think I could be described as a ‘tackle tart’,  but I do have a penchant for lures. It’s not like I’m addicted or anything (well maybe slightly, to one or two), but I love the search for the perfect lure that casts well, can be fished through anything or in any situation, is reasonably priced and catches huge bass every cast just using a straight retrieve. OK, there’s no such lure (if there is please let me know!), so I’m continually looking at different types of lures for bass fishing, hoping to discover (or rediscover) ones which will improve my results, and are best suited to the varied and changing way I fish.

I almost feel guilty, and a little fickle, in saying that my ‘go to’ soft plastic, the good old DoLive faced stiff competition from the Swimsenko in 2020. I started using this again, after reading a post on Mike Ladle’s blog; a fish on the very first cast and I was hooked, never mind the fish! I noticed that the paddle tail on this lure seemed to gee the fish up on the very small tides, when the DoLive seemed to struggle, so it’s now first choice at such times.

I’m generally late coming to the party in relation to lures. The SF125 is a case in point. I took pity on the one which had been languishing in the fishing drawer since my Ireland days. I  was repaid with almost instant success when I took it for a swim back in the summer, and it’s become a regular when fishing in roughish conditions in daylight – single barbless hooks and all. Likewise the classic Chug Bug, now adorned with two big singles, has finally proved its worth for me.

On a more contemporary note, 2020 saw me catching my first fish on the Autowalker 115S, the Dark Sleeper and, with thanks to angling buddy Stuart Martinez,  Mishna eels. Who knows what I’ll discover in 2021; I have a feeling that needlefish lures might make an appearance.

Captain Derek Goodwin MBE

I can’t close without a word about my good friend Derek Goodwin. As readers of my book will know, Derek is something of a legend, an inspiration to us all, for his hard work and dedication to conducting juvenile bass surveys over many years in Cornish estuaries. I was delighted to learn that he had been awarded the MBE for this work. I have been pleased to help Derek since 2013, and I can say that this award is richly deserved. I know that Derek is absolutely delighted, and so pleased that this important work has been recognised in this way.

Derek, making his way upriver to a survey site.

Roll on next season

Well, that’s me done fishing for now – time to hunker down for the rest of the winter I think. Let’s hope this year’s fishing is better than last!

I hope you and your family stay safe, and that things get back to something approaching normality just as soon as possible.

Featured image from Pixabay

10 Replies to “What happened to all the bass?”

  1. HNY Robin and thanks for the blog, keep em coming!
    Re the size of fish caught, I’ve struggled to get anything above 4lb this year off shore and the boat, I have done a lot more lure fishing this year and it’d be easy to say that’s the reason but it doesn’t explain the boat fishing…

    I’ve caught a lot (I don’t keep records) of fish under 3lb which is good to see but where are the big girls? There’s a lot brighter minds than mine who can assess all of the relevant information on that and come up with theories but the activities of commercials and illegal netters has to be top of any list. Whilst we have never been a part of the EU, I’m dreading the implications that Brexit will have on our fisheries. The work of SOSB is vital however the juggernaut they are up against is frightening.

    Still, our sport is awesome and allows us to get out there and meet some great people. On that note, hopefully you’ll be over in Guernsey sooner rather than later and we can go and catch some 🐟

    All the best,


    1. HNY to you too Bryn, good to hear from you.

      I hadn’t realised that you were even struggling in the Channel Islands; I think there’s a common theme here – commercial fishing.

      Even so, fishing on Guernsey is a great experience, and I’m very much looking forward to getting out with you again just as soon as this virus lets us.

  2. Hi Robin
    many thanks for taking the time to write about your 2020 season. For those of us who were unable to get to the coast (didn’t fish for bass even once last year) it’s a much-needed tonic to read about someone else’s catches … success or otherwise.

    Talking of bass catches of yesteryear … As you’ll know from the BASS committee emails and the forum, I’ve recently been involved in acquiring an item that demonstrates how big (huge) bass were once not so rare as the proverbial rocking horse do-do’s. It’s an original BASS badge, attached to which are 15 award tags … each one for a bass of 10lb in weight or above. These fish were caught by just one man. His name was Spencer Vibart and he lived in Plymouth and latterly in Camborne. He fished the Eddystone and was an expert at catching bass.
    Here’s a few examples:
    On one trip, in 1973, he caught 52 fish averaging 6lb, the best was 9 1/2lb. That year he also caught bass of: 11lb 4oz and 12lb 5oz
    In 1974 he caught bass of: 10lb 1oz, 10lb 8oz, 11lb 6oz and 14lb 8oz
    In 1975 he was awarded silver BASS badge bars for fish of 11lb 8oz, 11lb 15oz, and a gold bar for a fish of 15lb.
    In 1976 he caught bass of 10lb 12oz, 11lb 1oz, 11lb 5oz and 11lb 12 1/2oz. And those were just the silver award fish, because he was also awarded two gold bars that year for fish of 12lb 2oz and 13lb 9oz.
    The 2 biggest bass that he ever caught weighed 15lb 4oz and 16lb 2oz (1985)

    Will we ever see his record broken?

    1. Hi Steve.

      I’m glad you enjoyed the blog.

      Those catches of Spencer’s were truly remarkable. If only I had moved to Cornwall, and taken up bass fishing a few years earlier, I might even have been blessed with a magical double myself. But as each year passes the chances of this happening within my lifetime gets less and less.

  3. Love the blog Robin and agree with all of the content,
    This year I didn’t fish that often but when I did had some brilliant sessions. Like you, nothing much over 4lbs but the numbers were good with several sessions over 20 fish.

    I have started finding marks with deeper water and a tide run. Using 40g metal jigs-Zetz are my favourite-I am able to cast the jig way out into the tide and often hook fish on the drop.
    Hooking bass at long range in a tide is great sport and I also pick up decent pollack and a few mackerel for eating.
    On the soft lures the Storm Biscay 9recommended by Steve) have been excellent and you can catch a dozen bass on one and it stays usable. Sandy Andys are good fish catchers but are expensive and bass destroy them quickly.

    I have used the Gary Yamamoto senkos at night and love them. I use the plain 6″ white with no paddle and they slowly slalom through the water like a snake. You can see them from quite a distance on a moonlit night. I have got other colours but like the white.
    Hardly use diving hard plugs now now so might put a collection on the BASS forum for sale.
    Congratulations to Derek and thanks for all you do to help.

    1. Hi Peter. So glad you enjoyed the blog, and thanks for commenting.

      I’m interested in your experience of fishing deeper water in a tide run. I know we met up a couple of years ago, when I delivered that nice new rod you won at the BASS AGM, but we’ve never fished together, so perhaps we’ll meet up this year?

      You’ve reminded me about Senkos. This was another lure which proved itself for me in Cornwall this year, after discovering them in Ireland. I recall a 59cm bass slamming into a watermellon/pearl one at night during last summer.

  4. Hi Robin, great blog as normal, don’t give up on the double, my uncle caught his first bass over ten pounds well into his seventies, and he has fished for them all his life.

  5. Some interesting thoughts & information in there Robin.
    I’ve never caught on a Chug Bug, even though it has almost legendary status with some bass anglers.
    I think that we anglers can become to preoccupied by the different new lures that make appearances regularly. I certainly have in the past. My New Year resolution is not to buy anymore lures, but stick with the many that I have.
    I’ve never kept any accurate fishing logs or diaries over the years. Something that I now regret, as with age the memory can play tricks with you.
    I envy your collection of fishing diaries. And 2021 might be the year that I start keeping accurate fishing notes & records.

    1. Glad you found it interesting Nigel, and thanks for commenting.

      I have to thank Alan Vaughan for reacquainting me with the Chug Bug. Like you, I knew of its legendary status, but had never done that well on it. It was only talking to Alan that made me give it another go.

      I think that’s sound advice about lures, and I try not to get seduced by all the new ones which keep coming out – but the flesh is weak!

      I’ve always kept some sort of fishing record – I guess it’s the scientist in me. Before diaries it was 5×3″ cards (which I still have going back to the early eighties), but these didn’t allow me to record enough information. And then I realised that it was difficult to find information in the cards/diaries, so I started using a database/spreadsheet as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *